I tried to follow your P2P directions. For my last activation on 9 August at KFF-4595 I deliberately DID NOT claim any of the 4 P2P contacts. The reasoning being that you said if on claimed the P2P and the other did not then both would get credit.
It does not seem to have worked out that way. Under P2P I see the four contacts which means the others side must have claimed the P2P, but they are all un-confirmed.